First Heritage Insurance Agency Logo

Our Testimonials

If you’re looking for a local insurance provider you can trust to provide you with quality products and services, these testimonials about our insurance agency can help. First Heritage Insurance Agency is proud to offer our clients comprehensive coverage options from dependable carriers at competitive rates, and we’re grateful for the positive feedback about their experiences with us.

Insurance Agency Testimonials

Finding personal or commercial insurance quotes on your own can be a frustrating process, and it can also be challenging to find an insurance company you can trust. If you’re looking for an agency for your personal and commercial insurance needs, testimonials from current clients can help you confidently choose our established local agency to handle all of your insurance needs.

Our Clients Come First

At First Heritage Insurance Agency, our clients are our number one priority. We live and work in your community, so we understand your concerns regarding insurance coverage. We’d love to see you in person at our Huntington, NY office, and we’re also happy to help you over the phone or by email if that works better for your schedule.

Request a Free Insurance Quote

We’re a digital insurance agency, which means we have instant access to coverage options and quotes from dozens of reliable insurance carriers. We partner with companies we know are dependable, so you can be sure that the home, auto, life, or business policy you choose offers quality coverage. Because we’re able to search for policies from a wide range of companies, we can help you find one that suits your specific needs and bank account. We’ll help you every step of the way, and we’re always here to answer any questions or address any concerns you may have about your insurance coverage. Hablamos español.

Contact First Heritage Insurance Agency today at 631-659-2889 or request your free insurance quote here.

J. Graham

FHIA made it easy for me to get back on the road. It’s not easy to be available but with their friendly emails and quote forms, I was able to review quotes without speaking with them.

Agent: Matthew Gannon

B. Velez Diaz

My agent wasn’t pushy and was very patient with all my questions. Waited for me to make my decision as I asked. True customer service and I am saving money!

Agent: Ruddy Delarosa


Matt really listened and provided me with the best rates for exactly what I wanted. He was professional and patient with me.

Agent: Matthew Gannon

Linsdey O.

Excellent customer service. James is incredible and he helped fulfill everything I wanted and expected for my auto insurance policy. I asked a million questions and he answered each and every one of them without getting annoyed. By far the best Insurance Agency and Insurance agent I have ever had!

Agent Name: James Okula

Theresa S.

I am very pleased with the service I received today. Leanna was very informative and helped me tremendously. She was a Godsend to my needs. Thank you Leanna. You definitely are a person who makes a person feel comfortable. Great job and Kudos to you. Thank you again.

Agent Name: Leanna Estivo

Mojisola O.

I had the pleasure of working with Bradley Krill and throughout the whole process of setting up an auto and home insurance policy, he was a rock star! He was very attentive, try to give me the best quotes he could come up with, and overall I was very pleased and grateful to be able to work with him. I’m very excited about my journey with this agency!

Agent Name: Bradley Kril

Michaela C.

Ruddy is fantastic, he took so much time to help me out.. i had no idea what i was doing and he walked me through everything and was super patient. Amazing customer service.

Agent Name: Ruddy Acevedo

Christina B.

Excellent. Representative I spoke to had a wonderful personality and was very helpful. He helped me to find the best coverage and rate for my car. A+ for me!


Honestly they gave great service and tried to help me for weeks even if i didn’t have the full amount of money to insure my car. Consistent feedback and awesome service. Would definitely recommend giving them a call!!

Daniel L.

A great help with finding auto insurance, went through all the different companies and quotes for each. Helped me find the right one for me.

John N.

Great service and they found a great price in the really expensive NYC market.

Dipta P.

Do you want a good affordable quote with the best deals, great coverage and a game plan to save money? Then this is the best place to receive that. Agency, customer service and everything else was just truly an amazing experience. Not only did I save over 50% but I gained a lot of insight knowledge that I can now use for future reference. Thank You First Heritage Insurance and a shout out to my agent Ruddy. This guy is the man!

Agent Name: Ruddy Acevedo

Jasmine F.

Connor was very helpful, pleasant, professional, and took his time helping me find the best rate. I really appreciate his time and effort in helping me save on a new policy.

Agent Name: Connor McDonald

Our Hours

Monday - Friday 9 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Saturday 9 p.m. to 3 p.m.
Closed Sunday