First Heritage Insurance Agency Logo

Our Insurance Services

The thought of choosing a new insurance provider often induces stress and anxiety. At First Heritage Insurance Agency, we can help you skip the stress and jump right into the peace of mind that comes with knowing your biggest assets are protected. Unlike the automated online providers that offer one-size-fits-all services, we work with you to compare and customize your plan for the best fit. Our team of experienced agents will take the time to understand your goals, and we can even help you find extra savings by bundling services. We work with trusted names in insurance, including Progressive, Nationwide, The Hartford, Lancer Insurance, and National General, so you’ll get a competitive plan developed with our local expertise and knowledge of the industry. Browse our insurance services to find the right coverage.


Auto Insurance

Auto insurance isn’t just important, it’s required. Don’t risk driving uninsured. We offer plans for daily commuters and family drivers, as well as specialty insurance for your classic and collector cars. We can help you compare prices from different carriers to balance the right amount of coverage at a great price. In addition to the minimum liability coverage, we can also help you find comprehensive, collision, uninsured/underinsured motorist, and property damage options.

Handing Over Keys

Home Insurance

Home insurance protects your property in case of damage or theft. We offer dwelling and personal property coverage options, as well as flood insurance, business liability insurance if you run a business from your home, and family liability coverage for unexpected medical expenses or legal costs. We know that your home insurance needs are specific to your family and lifestyle, so we will work with you to create a completely customized plan.

Worker Making Drinks

Business Insurance

Running a business comes with many risks and rewards. Our team can help you minimize risks as your business grows with a commercial insurance policy that fits your needs. Choose from options including property insurance, general liability, commercial auto, and workers compensation plans. We also provide umbrella insurance to give you an additional layer of protection.

Get Started Today

Are you ready to switch to a carrier that cares about your needs? Our team at First Heritage Insurance Agency lives and works right here in your community. We serve all of New York City, as well as Nassau and Suffolk counties. Give us a call at 631-659-2889 to discuss your current policy and request a free quote for new coverage.

Our Hours

Monday - Friday 9am - 5pm
Closed Saturday and Sunday